Previous Issues:
 
32
March - April
2007
31
January - February
2007
30
November - December
2006
29
September - October
2006
28
July - August
2006
27
May - June
2006
26
March - April
2006
25
January - February
2006
24
November - December
2005
23
September - October
2005
22
July - August
2005
21
May - June
2005
20
March - April
2005
19
January - February
2005
IPR-Helpdesk Bulletin
2002 - 2004
 
 
  N. 33, May - June 2007 

IP in practice 
esp@cenet Quiz 
 

New Quiz


The moving alarm clock

When the alarm clock goes off and the snooze button is pressed, this innovative alarm clock will move away. Minutes later, when the alarm sounds again, the sleeper must get up out of bed and search for it to stop it. This ensures that the person is fully awake before turning it off. Try to find patents covering this innovative alarm clock.



Photo credit: Gauri Nanda, Media Lab. MIT

________________________________________________________


Solution to previous quiz

Electric cars are silent

Electric cars are coming and they are quieter than combustion vehicles. Many people cross the street without looking carefully when they do not hear anything. When you only have electrical cars, this may cause a problem. Why not have cars emit noise to prevent this type of accident? Try finding patents covering this concept.

Solution

Step one: To find similar patents, identify the most pertinent aspects of the invention -- common technical features that may be found in related patents -- and for each aspect, define a comprehensive set of synonyms. This set of synonyms can then be combined as keywords in the patent database.

In this case, the following concepts -- groups of synonyms covering the different aspects of the invention -- can be defined:

- nois*

- electric*

- car* vehic*

- pedestrian*

- accident, injur*

The combination nois* vehic* electric* pedes* yields a preliminary list containing some good documents.

Warning device for low-noise vehicle, JP2005343360

Running noise generator for running vehicle, JP2005253236

Sound generating device and automobile, JP2004136831

Additionally, searching the title field for the words noise electric* car* yields this additional interesting patent document:

Apparatus generating sound for electric car, US5517173

Usually we continue searching using classification symbols assigned to the most relevant documents. In this case, electrical vehicles could be covered by the B60L symbol. A quick search does not really yield many more documents. Deepening the search would be a must if this search has financial implications for your organisation: freedom to operate or a prior art search before filing a patent.

A quick search on the Internet produces some interesting references showing that issues do arise from silent electric cars, for blind people for instance: http://www.nfb.org/Images/nfb/Publications/bm/bm05/bm0506/bm050605.htm

http://www.treehugger.com/files/2006/03/are_silent_hybr.php